Skip to content
vseprchart

Electron Geometry vs Molecular Geometry

Electron geometry counts every domain, lone pairs included. Molecular geometry counts only atoms. Test yourself on the difference with the quiz below.

Score: 0 / 0

The difference in one line

Electron geometry is where all the electron domains point. Molecular geometry is where the atoms are. When the central atom has no lone pairs the two answers are the same; every lone pair makes them differ.

tetrahedral AX4 shape
Methaneelectron: tetrahedral · molecular: tetrahedral
bent AX2E2 shape
Waterelectron: tetrahedral · molecular: bent

In the right-hand picture the two translucent lobes are oxygen's lone pairs. Cover them with your thumb and what is left, two hydrogens at an angle, is the molecular geometry.

Every case where they differ

AXEElectron geometryMolecular geometryExamples
AX2Etrigonal planarbentSO2, O3
AX3Etetrahedraltrigonal pyramidalNH3, PCl3
AX2E2tetrahedralbentH2O, H2S
AX4Etrigonal bipyramidalseesawSF4, SeF4
AX3E2trigonal bipyramidalT-shapedClF3, BrF3
AX2E3trigonal bipyramidallinearXeF2, I3−
AX5Eoctahedralsquare pyramidalBrF5, IF5
AX4E2octahedralsquare planarXeF4, ICl4−

If the AXE class has no E, both geometries share one name; the VSEPR chart lists those rows too.

Which one is the question asking for?

  • "Electron geometry", "electron domain geometry", "electron pair geometry", "electron arrangement": count lone pairs.
  • "Molecular geometry", "molecular shape", "shape of the molecule": atoms only.
  • "Hybridization" follows the electron geometry: water is sp3 because its electron geometry is tetrahedral, not because it is bent.
  • "Polarity" depends on the molecular geometry: water is polar because it is bent.

Quick check

SO2: electron geometry and molecular geometry?

Three domains (2 O, 1 lone pair): trigonal planar electron geometry, bent molecular geometry.

XeF2: electron geometry and molecular geometry?

Five domains (2 F, 3 lone pairs): trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry, linear molecular geometry.

CO2: do the two geometries differ?

No. Carbon has two domains and no lone pairs, so both are linear.

The quiz at the top of the page deals random molecules and asks for the electron geometry; switch the question type to Molecular geometry to drill the other half.

Sources: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, §7.6 Molecular Structure and Polarity.

Electron vs molecular geometry questions

What is the difference between electron geometry and molecular geometry?

Electron geometry includes lone pairs; molecular geometry describes only the positions of atoms. They differ whenever the central atom has lone pairs.

When are electron geometry and molecular geometry the same?

When the central atom has no lone pairs, as in CO2, BF3, CH4, PCl5 and SF6.

What is the electron and molecular geometry of NH3?

Electron geometry tetrahedral (4 domains), molecular geometry trigonal pyramidal (3 atoms and 1 lone pair).

Is hybridization based on electron or molecular geometry?

On electron geometry, because every domain, lone pairs included, uses a hybrid orbital.